U.S. Supreme Court Grants Wheaton College Temporary Stay In Health Care Law Fight

Tribune illustration (July 1, 2014)
Tribune illustration (July 1, 2014)

The U.S. Supreme Court has granted Wheaton College a temporary stay in its fight against the federal health care law’s contraception mandate and will hear arguments Wednesday from lawyers representing the school and the White House about whether the injunction should continue.

The court’s decision in favor of the west suburban evangelical school came hours after its ruling Monday that closely held for-profit companies could be exempt from the same mandate on religious grounds. The mandate for nonprofits was scheduled to go into effect Tuesday.

“All Wheaton has asked for is protection while it litigates the case,” said Mark Rienzi, the lawyer representing Wheaton in the case.

Exactly 100 businesses, schools and organizations, 51 of them nonprofit, have sued the Obama administration over the mandate that employers provide health benefits that include all prescription contraceptives approved by the Food and Drug Administration.

If the stay is lifted and Wheaton opts to ignore the mandate and disregard the accommodation, it could face fines as high as $35 million a year, Rienzi said.

The Supreme Court for the first time Monday said a for-profit business owned by devout Christians can refuse to pay for some contraceptives for its female employees under the Affordable Care Act.

In that ruling, justices suggested that the government find another way to cover the cost, pointing to the Obama administration’s work-around for certain religious nonprofits in which insurers would provide and pay for the coverage, offset in some cases by a reduction in federal fees.

Wheaton would resist such an accommodation, Rienzi said.

“Because the government would require Wheaton to sign a form authorizing, directing, obligating, and incentivizing other parties to provide the contraceptives in Wheaton’s place, Wheaton can’t instruct someone to do things that it cannot do itself,” Rienzi said.

Click here to read more.

SOURCE: Chicago Tribune
Manya Brachear Pashman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *